Not a fact anymore

Rickets is caused primarily by infection or poor hygiene.

What we know now

Most nutritional rickets results from inadequate vitamin D, calcium, or phosphate. These shortages impair bone mineralization—the hardening of growing bone with calcium- and phosphate-rich mineral. Limited sunlight, diet, malabsorption, and some inherited disorders can all contribute.

Why it changed

Rickets was common in crowded industrial cities and often accompanied respiratory illness, making infection and hygiene plausible causes. Animal experiments, sunlight treatment, cod-liver oil, and vitamin D isolation established a nutritional and metabolic explanation.

Status
Overturned
Category
Medicine
Accepted for
≈69 years
Accepted approximately
19th–early 20th century
Changed approximately
1910s–1930s

Rickets became especially common in crowded industrial cities, where children often lived in dark housing, had poor diets, and suffered frequent infections. Those associations made infection, bad air, and poor hygiene plausible causal explanations.

Experiments gradually separated correlation from cause. Animal studies linked abnormal bone development to diet, while cod-liver oil could prevent or treat the disease.

Sunlight proved just as important. Children exposed to ultraviolet light improved, connecting rickets to a factor that the body could generate in skin.

That factor became identified as vitamin D, which is essential to calcium and phosphate metabolism and to mineralization—the process by which growing bone is hardened with mineral.

The new model also explained why rickets clustered in polluted northern cities: limited sunlight and restricted diets could occur together in the same disadvantaged populations that also experienced more infectious disease.

Not every case is caused by vitamin D deficiency alone. Calcium or phosphate deficiency, malabsorption, liver or kidney disease, and inherited disorders can also produce rickets.

The key correction was causal: infection could accompany the disease without being its primary explanation.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Previous belief

Historical context

Current evidence

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: