Not a fact anymore

Dreams occur only during REM sleep.

What we know now

Dreaming can occur during both REM and non-REM sleep. REM dreams are often more vivid and story-like, but non-REM awakenings can also produce detailed dream reports.

Why it changed

After REM sleep was discovered in 1953, its strong association with vivid dream reports led many researchers to equate REM with dreaming. Later awakenings from non-REM sleep and brain-imaging studies showed that dream experience is not confined to one stage.

Status
Overturned
Category
Neuroscience
Accepted for
≈7 years
Accepted approximately
1950s–1970s
Changed approximately
1960s–2000s

The discovery of rapid eye movement sleep in the 1950s seemed to offer an objective physiological marker for something previously accessible mainly through subjective reports. When researchers awakened sleepers during REM, they frequently obtained vivid accounts of dreams. Awakenings from other stages produced dream reports less often.

That strong association was easy to turn into an identity: REM sleep is dreaming. But the experimental method also provided the means to test the claim. Researchers who systematically awakened people during non-REM sleep found that they too could report imagery, thoughts and sometimes elaborate dream experiences.

Later neurophysiology and brain-imaging work reinforced the separation between a sleep stage and the conscious experience occurring within it. REM remains especially associated with vivid, emotional and story-like dreams, but it is neither necessary for every dream nor a guarantee that a remembered dream report will follow.

Dream research always has a measurement problem: investigators normally know that a dream occurred because a person wakes and reports it. Recall therefore depends on timing and memory as well as on the underlying sleep state.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Previous belief

Historical context

Current evidence

  • What happens during sleep?Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development

    Explains that dreams are usually most vivid during REM but can also occur during non-REM sleep.

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: