Not a fact anymore

Every eukaryotic organism retains mitochondria or a reduced version of them.

What we know now

Some single-celled eukaryotes have lost the mitochondrial organelle altogether. Monocercomonoides exilis survives without it, using a bacterial-derived system in the surrounding cell fluid to assemble essential iron–sulfur components of proteins.

Why it changed

A 2016 genome study found none of the usual mitochondrial machinery in Monocercomonoides, but did find a replacement for an essential mitochondrial function. Comparative work in 2023 supported complete loss in two other related species.

Status
Overturned
Category
Cell Biology
Accepted for
Not quantified
Accepted approximately
Early 2000s–2016
Changed approximately
2016, with further comparative evidence in 2023

Eukaryotes are the organisms whose cells contain a nucleus: animals, plants, fungi and many microbes. Mitochondria are best known for supplying usable energy, but they also perform other important chemistry.

Some oxygen-poor environments contain eukaryotes with tiny, highly altered mitochondrial descendants. Finding these remnants in organisms once thought to lack mitochondria helped establish a new consensus: the organelle could shrink dramatically, but every living eukaryotic lineage still retained it in some form.

Then a microbe from a chinchilla’s gut broke the rule.

In 2016, researchers investigated the genome of the organism now named Monocercomonoides exilis. They could not find the machinery normally associated with mitochondria. Instead, a system acquired from bacteria could perform iron–sulfur cluster assembly outside the organelle. These small chemical components help essential proteins work.

This was not a surviving organism from before mitochondria evolved. The evidence pointed to a descendant of mitochondria-bearing ancestors that had lost the organelle. A 2023 comparison supported the same loss in two relatives.

The exception concerns whole organisms and evolutionary lineages. It is different from a specialized cell, such as a mature human red blood cell, losing its mitochondria during development.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Previous belief

Primary research

  • A Eukaryote without a Mitochondrial OrganelleCurrent Biology

    The 2016 study found no mitochondrial hallmark proteins and identified a bacterial-derived replacement for iron–sulfur cluster assembly. It inferred secondary loss of the organelle.

Historical context

Current evidence

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: