Not a fact anymore

Routine episiotomy prevents severe tearing, protects the pelvic floor, and improves childbirth outcomes.

What we know now

Routine episiotomy does not provide those broad benefits and can increase pain, blood loss, healing problems, and serious perineal injury. Restrictive use produces better outcomes for most spontaneous vaginal births.

Why it changed

Episiotomy became standard practice during the 20th century despite weak supporting evidence. Randomized trials and systematic reviews found that routine cutting did not prevent the injuries it was supposed to avoid.

Status
Overturned
Category
Medicine
Accepted for
≈69 years
Accepted approximately
Early to late 20th century
Changed approximately
1980s–2000s

An episiotomy is a surgical cut in the perineum, the tissue between the vaginal opening and the anus. It was introduced as a controlled incision that could replace an unpredictable natural tear. The logic was persuasive: a clean incision might heal better, prevent severe perineal injury, protect the pelvic floor, and speed delivery.

During the twentieth century, the procedure became routine in many hospitals even though those preventive benefits had not been established by strong trials.

Comparative studies reversed the assumption. Routine episiotomy did not reliably prevent severe tearing or later pelvic-floor problems and could itself increase pain, blood loss, healing difficulty, and extension into more serious injury.

A restrictive strategy—using episiotomy only when there is a specific indication—produced better overall outcomes for most spontaneous vaginal births and became the recommended approach.

Episiotomy has not disappeared. It can still be appropriate in selected assisted or urgent deliveries or when clinicians judge that enlarging the vaginal opening is necessary.

The overturned claim is the population-wide preventive rule: routinely cutting the perineum does not protect mothers better than selective use.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Previous belief

Current evidence

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: