Not a fact anymore

The laws of physics always treat a process and its mirror image identically.

What we know now

The weak interaction—the force involved in radioactive beta decay—does not always treat a process and its mirror image the same way. In weak decays, nature can distinguish left from right. Electromagnetic and strong interactions still preserve this mirror symmetry.

Why it changed

Physicists had assumed that mirror symmetry, or parity, was a universal law. In 1956, Lee and Yang noticed that it had never been directly tested in weak interactions. Chien-Shiung Wu and colleagues then tested beta decay in cobalt-60 and found a clear left-right asymmetry.

Status
Overturned
Category
Physics
Accepted for
≈32 years
Accepted approximately
1920s–1956
Changed approximately
1956–1957

Imagine filming a physical experiment and then watching its mirror image. Parity symmetry says that the mirrored experiment should still obey the same laws: nature should not have a built-in preference for left over right.

By the mid-twentieth century, this symmetry had worked so reliably that physicists treated parity conservation as a fundamental rule. But in 1956, Tsung-Dao Lee and Chen-Ning Yang noticed an important gap. Parity had been tested in electromagnetic and strong interactions, but not directly in the weak interaction, which is involved in radioactive beta decay.

Chien-Shiung Wu and collaborators performed the crucial test with cobalt-60. They aligned the radioactive nuclei and measured the directions in which electrons were emitted during beta decay. If parity were conserved, the mirrored arrangement would be equally likely. Instead, the electrons showed a preferred direction.

The weak interaction really does distinguish left from right. That did not make parity useless: electromagnetic and strong interactions still preserve it to extremely high precision. What disappeared was the belief that mirror symmetry had to hold for every fundamental interaction.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Previous belief

Historical context

Current evidence

  • Cracks in the MirrorAmerican Physical Society

    Recounts the rapid experimental confirmation that weak decays violate mirror symmetry.

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: