Not a fact anymore

Gamma-ray bursts come from neutron stars within the Milky Way.

What we know now

Most gamma-ray bursts are enormous explosions in distant galaxies, not ordinary events inside the Milky Way. Long bursts are linked to the collapse of massive stars, while many short bursts come from mergers of compact objects such as neutron stars.

Why it changed

Gamma-ray bursts appeared briefly and then vanished, so early astronomers had little way to measure their distance and many models placed them around neutron stars in our Galaxy. BATSE later found the bursts spread almost evenly across the sky, and in 1997 fading afterglows allowed redshift measurements that placed bursts billions of light-years away.

Status
Overturned
Category
Astronomy
Accepted for
≈22 years
Accepted approximately
1970s–early 1990s
Changed approximately
1991–1997

Gamma-ray bursts are sudden flashes of extremely energetic radiation. They can last from a fraction of a second to several minutes and then disappear.

When satellites discovered them in the late 1960s, astronomers had almost no information about how far away they were. Neutron stars in the Milky Way offered plausible sources, so Galactic models dominated much of the early debate.

NASA’s Compton Gamma Ray Observatory changed the picture. Its BATSE instrument detected bursts all across the sky. If most came from ordinary objects in the Milky Way’s flat disk, they should have appeared concentrated along the bright band of the Galaxy. Instead, the distribution was almost uniform in every direction.

That was a serious problem for simple Galactic models, but it did not yet prove that the bursts were extremely distant. A huge spherical halo around the Milky Way could also look nearly uniform from Earth.

The decisive evidence came in 1997. Satellites began locating bursts quickly enough for telescopes to observe their fading afterglows in visible light and other wavelengths. Astronomers could then measure redshift, the stretching of light toward longer wavelengths as the universe expands, and identify host galaxies. The bursts were billions of light-years away.

That distance meant their energy output was enormous. Later observations connected long bursts with the deaths of massive stars and many short bursts with mergers involving neutron stars.

Some gamma-ray transients do occur inside the Milky Way, but the classical gamma-ray bursts at the center of the old distance debate are mostly cosmological.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Previous belief

Historical context

  • Gamma-Ray BurstsNASA HEASARC

    Explains that BATSE disproved the previously favored Galactic-disk distribution and prompted a shift to cosmological distances.

Current evidence

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: